Overheard on the Internets

Bill Mahr's Religulous

Watch the whole thing on Google Video now. Catch it before they take it down.

http://video.google.com/googleplayer.swf?docid=-1839369108234002661&hl=en&fs=true


"In The Play of Man, Groos extended his insights about animal play to humans. He pointed out that human beings, much more so than any other species, must learn different skills depending on the society in which they develop. Therefore, he argued, natural selection led to a strong drive, in human children, to observe the activities of their elders and incorporate those activities into their play. Children in every culture play at the general categories of activities that are essential to people everywhere, but their specific forms of play, within each category, are shaped by the kinds of activities they see around them. When children are free, they play far more, and in a far greater variety of ways, than do the young of any other species because they have far more to learn."


Owyang digs up the Air Force blog response flowchart. 
Airforblog
From Grant McCracken: "I think some people in marketing continue to work with a narrow view.  And I am sure it feels to them like an act of discipline.  "Look how closely we scrutinize the consumer.  Look how microscopic is our view!"  But of course, as Lafley and Charan point out, this eliminates from view the very things that make the life make sense and opportunities come to view. "

The healing begins...

Creating Local Currency, Sleeping On Couches, Investing in Farm Shares, etc..

"Advertising agencies have dabbled in side businesses for decades, but “inventing their own brand, not dependent on clients’ largess, is the big new thing,” said George Parker, an ad agency consultant and writer of AdScam, a blog about the industry. As the economy worsens and ad budgets tighten, “the creation of intellectual property and new products is something you’re going to see a lot more of,” he said."

Esurance and Cool Credits

Just saw this spot for Esurance come across the telly. Although I appreciate the intent to publicize a relatively unknown band, it may be a little obtuse to the importance of the discovery process. The hope, I presume, is that the audience, elated by the new find, dubs Esurance with a cool credit.

It's possible that I'm far too much of a music snob to understand how most people actually find music, but the massification of putting the band name on the screen sort of ruins the bit of joy one (okay, me) feels when coming across a good up and comer.  It lets everyone "in on the joke" and strips away the shareability. 

As Tim Smith said, "Marketers of the future will not be measured by how well they tell stories to their audience, but rather by how well their audience tells stories about them."

So why take away that story? 

If they had just left the name off, it'd still take an act from me to find the name. While that may seem somewhat somewhat frivolous, it's the act of searching that makes the find more fulfilling. Plus, what do I gain by sharing something everyone already knows about?

Anyway - have you guys checked out that Michael Jackson song, Thriller? I mean, wow. Like seriously...

Inspiration vs. Motivation

"Inspiration is short-lived. It’s typically emulating other people, and it’ll push us for a week or two. But inspiration begins to extinguish quite quickly. And as Henry Ford once said, after that it’s 90 percent hard work. Inspiration may get us started, but it never keeps us going. And that’s where motivation works.  

And motivation doesn’t come in a bottle. Motivation is, scientifically speaking, a series of small behaviors."

Apparently this is quote week. This one comes from John Norcross via Rob Walker of Murketing. It's a fantastically interesting way to think about what's wrong with advertising today, constantly trying to inspire the consumer to buy in fleeting forms, without doing the generally harder and more difficult to measure work of consistently motivating a person to purchase.

Rob probably said it better (that's why he's got that fancy job at the NYTimes)

"Anyway, I guess I wonder if all the inspiration offered by gurus is a bit of a disservice. It’s like a jolt of caffeine; it won’t last. (It’s another variation of the instant-ness problem I wrote about the other day, maybe.) You’ll feel briefly like you’re on a new path, but it fades. You get pumped up and “inspired,” and then before long you’re right back where you were … needing “inspiration” again."


(Feel free to stop reading here - the rest of this is just thinking out loud)

***

Heyjealousy1All of this makes me wonder what we actually value as a society. We like to think it's the underdog story, the guy who works his way up from nothing to the top. But is that what we really value in practice? 

Gladwell touches on this in Outliers. We imagine these great people as if they were born to do what they do. Not so much that they fell into success, but that it was somehow pre-destined for them. And in doing so we discount the serious work that it took to succeed, as well as the help that pushed them to what they become.

Or consider Tony Romo after the very sad defeat the Cowboys were handed yesterday. He started off the year a brilliant underdog story, a guy that worked his way up from a small town, to division 2 college football, to barely making the team as an undrafted rookie free agent. But now the hard work story is rather worthless, lost to a single average season.

Or stock prices. An entire financial system based on short-term returns, often at the expense of longer-term gains. Last night I heard a pundit talking about how next year probably won't be so bad because we'll be rolling over this year's sales. So even if next year still sucks, the comps will probably be positive, and stocks go up. Or when a new CEO is hired, he or she lays off 20% of the staff, closes a few stores - and the stocks go up. Doesn't mean they'll make any more money or be much healthier in reality, but stocks go up, discounting the much more difficult job of actually making a company viable again.

The point is maybe what we really value is the winning, but we don't really give a shit about how we do it, no matter what story we tell ourselves. Maybe it's all just based on envy. Everyone envies the end result, but not necessarily for the sacrifice that it took to create it, so we choose to discount the difficult bits as it might negatively affect the story of what we tell ourselves success looks like.

Anyway - probably neither here nor there, but something to think about.

The Persuaders

"Every effort to break through the clutter is just more clutter. Ultimately, if you don’t have clean, plain borders and backdrops for your ads, if you don’t have that blank space, that commons, that virgin territory, you have a very hard time making yourself heard. The most obvious metaphor is a room full of people, all screaming to be heard. What this really means, finally, is that advertising is asphyxiating itself."


-Mark Crispin Miller, from the PBS's Frontline documentary, the Persuaders.

Sounds about right, no? Although the documentary is about 4 years old, the argument presented seems roughly the same as we're having today, except with fewer references to social media, of course. Which on some level makes today's argument seem a little stale. But maybe that has more to do with Frontline's depiction of advertising folks. You'll probably feel a little dirty after watching this.

As a side note, check out the PBS library of content for some cool stuff. There isn't shit on TV this time of year, so if you want to get all learned up, this is probably a good place to start. You might also check out The Merchants of Cool if you'd like to get a gander at a short-haired Malcom Gladwell.

Find the Purpose. Make a Movement.

To find our purpose, ours and our audience’s, we must create movements. That means using our influence to create a social good. We win by all of us winning. 

Engagement-chain120908

Engagement as a metric has been largely misused as a simple act, no matter the act, as an indication of commitment. An interaction with a banner ad, whether intended or not, this is engagement. Curiosity by shock, attention by near nudity, these would be considered engagement by most models. But this is engagement in the ephemeral, not the beginning of a meaningful alliance. 

Engagement that matters is about caring. It’s the feeling an underdog might experience after pulling an upset. It’s the audience leaning forward with a communal want. 

These experiences can’t simply be created by price points or USPs, and advertising’s big ideas are mostly far too small to cause these social movements that are defined by real behavioral changes. People believe in the authentic. People believe in things they feel matter, both personally and culturally. To expect them to believe in you means you must obsess over more than bottom lines and share their thirst to leave behind something better than came before. 

A professor at the London Business School, Patrick Barwise, simply said, “Often our biggest mistake as managers is believing that, in general, customers care a lot about your brand. They do not.” 

This is our truth. People don’t generally care about brands. They don’t care much about what we say, the logo or the color of the stationary. But they could care very much for what we do. With Evolution, Dove expanded sales by exposing the falsehoods around model culture, but also funded real efforts to change what young women saw when they looked in the mirror. 


When Haagen-Dazs supported the movement to save the Honey Bee, they didn’t just make ads, they created new products and went to the senate floor to plead their case.

 Our goal is not simply to move more products in the name of moving more products, but understanding a brand’s cultural relevancy, creating stronger relationships through social movements and ultimately accomplishing business objectives by enriching the people we serve.

Tune In Saturdays: J. Tillman

For any fans of Fleet Foxes or Bon Iver, prepare for your pants to go crazy for Seattle's J. Tillman (also known as Josh). Although this is his 5th studio release, it's his first since becoming the drummer for the Fleet Foxes. Most of his earlier work, including the video below, is about as minimalist as they come, but with Vacilando Territory Blues, he's adding additional elements while keeping the original folksy style.


"It is heavily apparent that Tillman is going to find widespread success eventually, and it looks to be quite soon too with the upcoming release of Vacilando Territory Blues on January 20th. Coinciding with how his albums seem to get better with each passing one, Tillman’s newest effort proves to be his most consistent to date. While other January releases from the likes of Animal Collective, Franz Ferdinand, and Andrew Bird may be receiving the most attention at this point and time, it would be a shame to overlook this gem. I will say this much: If it were being released this year, I would have to shuffle around some albums to make room for it on my Top 50."



J. Tillman - First Born (mp3)
J. Tillman - Seven States Across (video)

Tune In Saturdays: Plants and Animals

PlantsandanimalsAnother in a pretty much constant stream of Canadian talent, trio Plants and Animals brings an ambitious, folksy-ish, but malleable record with Parc Avenue. At times southern rocky, and at others classic rock & Fleetwood Mac-y, the album has one unexpected gem after another.


From Pitchfork:
 

"They offer up explosive, Polyphonic Spree-sized choir choruses, 1970s AM radio guitars, cozy folk balladry, and rambling stoner boogie-often in the course of one song-- and switch between them with little warning. Many of their songs clock in at over five minutes long, but that's all the better for them to pick up steam, stylistically mutate, or expand."


Plants and Animals - Good Friend (mp3)
Plants and Animals - Bye Bye Bye (video)

Disturbing Commercial News

A planner walks in the room, sits down across the table from a team of disinterested creatives. She sternly ruffles through her papers to find her just completed creative brief.

She says, "Listen guys, we've gone about as far as we can go with this whole 'squeezably soft' thing. There are far too many other soft brands on the market. We've done double soft, triple-layered and quardruple protection. The research indicates that a quint is simply not a credible claim.  We've lost our USP. But I've got something even better."

The creatives lean forward, listening intently for the first time.

The planner continues,"so here it is, the new proposition is...we don't leave specs of soiled toilet paper stuck to your bum."

Silence befalls the room.

"So your challenge is to tell people we don't leave the specs without inducing a collective audience vomit."

The creatives gleefully exchange glances around the room before shouting in unison, "Bears!"


And thus this disturbing fail whale was begat.


As Heard in the World Wide Tubes.

Russell Davies and the Algorithm

Who knew the big RD was a closet stat guy? I couldn't agree more. While I think we're moving towards creating behavioral shifts through action, not simply communication - the basics of advertising, the stuff still valuable in terms of reach and frequency - will be a much more scientific endeavor.


"The spoils will go to he or she who accumulates the most data from their users and whose mathematicians can devise the most subtle and cunning algorithms for recommendation. It's a battle about maths. And as more marketing and services become about the management and analysis of masses of consumer and media data we're only going to see more of these kinds of contests. It's always seemed inevitable to me that media planning and buying will one day go this way. How long can it be before huge planning and buying departments are replaced by a little PC in the corner, tended by a couple of statisticians, grinding through algorithms?"


A behind the scenes peek at the logos not picked to become the badge of the Obama brand. Good thing they picked the one they did.


via adlab - and this is sort of self-explanatory.


Plenty of juicy graphs to steal for your next presentation from the authors of Groundswell.


Groundswell 
7. Cocaine, 6. Alcohol, 5. Valium, 4. Heroin, 3. Cigarettes, 2. Potato Chips, 1. Love. Who knew? 


The perils of Facebook for the young and accomplished Jon Favreau.
Favreau-facebook
A pretty cool mini-doc of Camp Organic, the somewhat self-indulgent boot camp from the boys and girls at the biggest little digital shop. (The vid below is from a couple years ago, though. Apparently this years wasn't good enough to offer an embed on YouTube. Caution - respect declining quickly...)


Only a few days left til Christmas. If you're still struggling, let Darryland the Plaid Nation lead the way.



CMO: Holy shit,this viral thing is gonna be huge!
Staffer: Yeah, Domino's did one not too long ago.
CMO: What the fuck? You idiot! Where is our viral? Give me viral, damnit!
Staffer: But...
CMO: Now!


And Pizza Hut demeans us all with this horribly unfunny, off-brand, waste of time. (Side note: why not tag this pizza hut, as if no one knew that thiis was paid? Seriously, I tried searching for Pizza Hut and YouTube and couldn't find it.


 

And for the "But they got 200k views!!" crowd. This has more (and is awesome).


Kids + Money

For you guys that do have a subscription to HBO, I highly recommend you set your Tivo for Kids + Money by Lauren Greenfield. It's a fantastic peek into the thoughts of various teens and pre-teens on consumer culture. It's basically a series of interview "portraits" of kids from various economic backgrounds in LA.


From Phoebe:

In L.A., the money is on the surface level. When you meet someone, it’s like, “Hi. I’m this person. I’m rich,” or “Hi, I’m this person. I wish I was rich.” It shows up everywhere. How tan you are, what jewelry you’re wearing. Girls have $3000 book bags just for school. It doesn’t stop in high school—what car you drive, where you work, what kind of suit you are wearing. It’s a whole image thing that Hollywood forces you to fit into.


And below is the trailer:


[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVq3bnQhass&w=425&h=344]