DR vs. Branding, Again.

Purchase_funnelThe theme of this years ad:tech San Francisco was "Brand Strategy and the Expanding World of Digital Marketing," which served as somewhat of a guidepost for the content of the talks, but also to highlight the spreading divide that's happening across the digital advertising industry. A quick stroll through exhibitors alley will give you booth after booth of lead generation, affiliate and CPA technology services looking to fulfill your direct response needs, but far less products to make your branding efforts really sing.

On the other side of the floor, there were still plenty of conversations dealing with the a direct response, heavily metrics driven world that is the most pervasive method on the web, but also more clearly showed the shift that's happening now. As I said in this post, the internet really began as a beacon for advanced metrics, a fantasy world for brands who thought they could know the exact return for every dollar spent.

But finally, as more brands and agencies begin to understand that the web is also a marketplace for interaction and attention, we've seen marketers move beyond just the final step at the end of a purchase funnel. And as director of marketing for ask.com, Sean X, said (at least roughly), ignore the top of the funnel at your peril.

So you won't see some long winded post summarizing each panel or speaker on the event, mainly because Cam and Ryan have done it better than I can. But there's clearly change happening in the industry. It reflects not only a new sense of realism about what the net provides, but also the possibilities of what it could provide.

That said, the highlight was the time spent with my blogger social and madison avenue journal cohorts Cam, Ryan, Sean and Katie. I get the feeling we all need more conversations (or an arguments) about change in the industry because most people out there are struggling enough to just do what they do every day. It's more than a little humbling to spend that much time with that much brain power. Truly a pleasure boys and girls.

photo by stebbi

Live from Ad:Tech, Day One

Logo_adtech_sfTomorrow morning kicks off 3 days chocked full of advertising shenanigans with ad:tech San Francisco. The Madison Avenue Journal brought a team of bloggers to cover the event, shake some hands, kiss some babies and probably drool over some of the latest advertising technologies. You might even hear a healthy dose of advertis-y cynicism.

Follow the fun from the mothership, TMAJ, and I'm sure each of us will be chiming in from time to time. (including Matt, Cam, Ryan, Katie, Sean and Eric)

The first roundtable gets started with a topic near and dear to all of our hearts, "The Art of Conversation: Building Great Brands in the Digital Age" featuring Pete Blackshaw, Tom Asher, Beth Thomas-Kim, Jordan Warren, Todd Cunningham and Tom Clancy's possible brother, Rick Clancy.

To what extent does listening and conversation share a symbiotic relationship? Brands must transition from monologue to dialogue in the era of consumer control, but how do they proactively engage and converse with consumers?

The rest of the day is full of tough choices, Follow the Money or Tales from the Bleeding Edge? Multi-Platform world or Futuresearch? State of Online Video or the Modern Agency? The Internet Economy or Social Network Marketing? Luckily, I'm a skilled party-hopper, so I plan on getting as much of each as I can. Hopefully I'll report back with some poor-quality video and photos. I might even catch a certain presidential candidate speaking a little too plainly about small town America. You never know. It is San Francisco.

Tune In Saturdays: Norfolk & Western

NorfolkThis week, Portland's own, star-studded Norfolk & Western caught my ear with a beautifully lush record from 2006 called The Unsung Colony. Featuring members from M. Ward and the Decemberists, N&W again and again manage to be both big and understated, both strange and simple, effortlessly. It may be a little hard to classify, but it's full of a folksy, country-ish backbone. Great stuff.

From PopMatters:

The Unsung Colony is damn fine, near perfect, each elegant orchestrated folk-pop song given greater resonance by its placement in the album’s waxing and waning—even the not-as-good ones, and they’re all at least pretty good.  Some, like the epic “Arrangements Made” are exceptional, an inspired blend of the Flaming Lips, Harry Nilsson, and the White Album.  Featuring such accomplished scenesters as Rachel Blumberg (the Decemberists) and Peter Broderick (Horse Feathers) playing all manner of string, key, and horn, The Unsung Colony should establish mastermind Adam Selzer as a pretty major player on the autumnal/prog-quaint circuit, or whatever the kids call it these days.

Norfolk & Western - The Longest Stare (mp3)
Norfolk & Western - The Gilded Age (video)

Brand Strategy and the Roll of Digital Marketing

From the latest Madison Avenue Journal article in support of Ad:Tech SF...

Hands_in_the_air The internet has been touted as a place where knowledge is power, data is everything, and where advertising will finally be proven past Wanamaker's 50/50 proposition. ROI will reign supreme. Finally every dollar will be accountable for an immediate return.

Of course, much of this is true. We can know more about each interaction than any other media, and we should use all the information we can to prove and improve our efforts. But brand strategists are understanding the need to recognize all factors that cause a purchase. Not only those that move people to purchase, but also towards purchase. It's a subtle difference, I know, but an important one as perceived accountability can overtake the need to increase consumer identification with your brand. The yet-to-die pop up is enough proof of that.

In this performance market where metrics reign supreme, it can become increasingly difficult to move beyond the click, beyond the ultimate conversion even, and to realize it's not necessarily about the last touch point, but the culmination of all touch points, controlled and uncontrolled, permitted or not, to move a customer to purchase.

And in a tomorrow when the banner crutch is removed by increasingly pervasive ad blocking technology, meaning will be king. Relevancy will be what matters. We stop just saying that "we are the low price leader" or "we have the best selection" and move on to "we are the brand that people like you buy."

Richard Huntington, Director of Strategy at Saatchi & Saatchi London, said, "It is vital to be interesting. It is merely important to be right."

And nowhere is this more profound than here, the most difficult place to expose your brand. In this place where you don't matter, where no one is forced to spend time with you. It's an economy where money is less important and the more you force interaction, the more the audience may pull away. Interesting and good are more important qualities than anything else, and here, the quest for the immediate return can sometimes harm your chances for long term profitability.

The golden promise of ROI-focused banner buys is that we will move people at the bottom of the funnel, the mini-minority ready to buy, through to the purchase, discounting the brand metrics that may have been moved by each previous interaction between the brand and the purchaser.

It is in this place that the brand strategist can truly shine.

6_web_20_logos With more tools than ever before, she can more easily know what the marketplace believes, what it says when it thinks no one is paying attention, where the trends are, and what things are the most important. And while all these tools definitely make the job easier, it's begun to redefine what branding really means.

A good steward of the brand in the traditional world might mean someone who keeps the messaging "on brand." It's someone who looks at things like price, promotion, place, people and product to define what it is exactly. In this new world of marketing, brand strategists will be advocates for the brand in different ways. She may stand up for these brand ideals, but more by becoming conversationalists than stalwarts of a singular position. She must work harder to listen and encourage other conversation, as well. A brand is built not just by the things that you are, but how you act in this marketplace. It's a much more intimate skill.

"Smart marketers will start to measure how many fans their business page has and how many users their Facebook application has, for example. They will also get their entire executive team onto Facebook. Smart marketers will use Facebook ads, events, groups, business pages and applications to find and communicate with their best future customers." Mike Volpe, Hubspot

Even so, we increasingly see how brand strategy can directly affect these ROI metrics. For instance, building a blog or creating a social media strategy can not only push those branding measurements, it can also improve simple conversion metrics by strengthening organic search placements.

"In the US, roughly 80% of internet use (excluding e-mail) begins with a search. And a majority of business purchasers use the internet for research before a purchase is made. Blogging gives a company a lot of content containing a lot of keywords, and, with a lot of incoming and outbound links, that's SEO gold." Kevin Tomzak Power Up

New media tools can be used to expand not only relevancy, but bring the brand closer to people in many different places, and in the ways they feel most comfortable. Sure, the brand may not always look exactly the same, or say the exact same things, but if these tools are to be effective in humanizing a brand, they most certainly can't. Engaging people and interesting brands are formed on the back of layered stories and the element of surprise. Consistent and dependable are needed attributes to have, but lack what it takes to make a customer HAVE to take the risk of telling their friends about their experience.

7_lost Just look at what LOST, Heroes or even the Office has created in their own ways. While the majority of the audience will only engage with the television show, these networks have also armed their biggest fans with the tools to watch and re-watch shows online, get to know the characters better and differently, and understand more deeply the totality of the story. It doesn't necessarily hurt any of these shows if the viewer is not all the way involved, but it provides these brand fans a much tighter connection to the show and community it spurred, as well as keeps the conversation going not only while the show is running, but in the slow months. Believe me, it's a valuable opportunity for these networks.

"The Long Tail audience expects to be communicated with appropriately based on the tools of the hour. And they'll want to participate, mash-up and be a part of the conversation. Be prepared to shorten approval processes, let go of production standards, and press record." Darryl Ohrt, Brand Flakes for Breakfast

Obviously the entertainment industry plays nicely into the practice of brand-building on the internet, but many companies seem relegated to the fact that they are not a charismatic brand. A brand could decide that they only sell tissues, or soda, or some other product that's less likely to inflame the passions of the target audience.

Green_grass But there's the opportunity for us in this new web. And by us, I mean all advertisers, large and small, now inherently interesting or not. We have to become content creators on the web with the intent of not only drawing our customers closer to us, but by going to where they are to become closer to them. With so many tools, we have more opportunity than ever before to be branded as real, authentic, emotional, and above all else, interesting. To be anything less is to not exist in this, the populist web.

TechCrunch Sues Facebook for $25M (updated with Paul's admission of idiocy)

DO NOT GO ANY FURTHER. YOUR OPINION OF ME WILL BE SEVERELY LOWERED!   

Okay, maybe I should have looked at the date. April Fool's Day on me. Fuck! At least I caught it before it actually got to be April 1. At least I have that going for me.

With that, I am officially suing Techcrunch for defamation of character. 50 million dollars. Pay up now, bitches.

Anyway, on with nonsense...

Facebook Beacon + Triple Soy Latte = Lawsuit

Facebooksue1 Seems TechCrunch founder Michael Arrington has gotten fed up with the Beacon platform using his likeness to shill for Blockbuster, along with various advertisers signed up in the program. It'll be interesting to see if this thing actually gets all the way to court. Arrington & co. claim they are due $150 million dollars under California law, but are willing to settle out of court for the equivalent of $25 million in Facebook stock.

From TechCrunch:

"So we’ve been increasingly concerned about developments at Facebook over the last few months that allow advertisers to post ads using my picture and name to endorse their products without my explicit permission. I’ve received literally dozens of emails from readers asking me if I’m associated with Blockbuster’s Movie Clique application, or the new Jackass movie (no to both)."

"I am sad that this had to blow up to the point where we are publicly suing Facebook over the matter. We’ll be filing the lawsuit tomorrow along with a related civil case for assault and battery. In a round of negotiations over the lawsuit with Facebook led by Chief Privacy Officer Chris Kelly, things got out of hand. When our team of lawyers offered to settle for a mere $50 million, Kelly told me Facebook would “bury you and bury your crappy blog” if we filed the suit. He then threw his steaming hot triple soy latte espresso at me, which caused extensive second degree burns over the top half of my body. Later on, he also unfriended me."

We'll see how this all plays out. If Arrington gets his pay day, I'd be willing to bet we'd see some big changes happening fairly quickly. Even if the lawsuit is a bit of a reach, I would say that Chris Kelly's actions are pretty shocking. That said, Arrington is no butterfly, so I'd like to hear how things got to that point in the first place. Though not much would justify that reaction. Especially the de-friending. That seems especially brutal.

Tune In Saturdays (sort of): The Ruby Suns

Ruby_sunsThis week, we'll feature New Zealand by-way-of-Los Angeles orchestral pop rock band, The Ruby Suns.I'd describe them as a little bit Animal Collective, a little bit Polyphonic Spree, mixed with a lot of crazy sounds and happy harmonies. Fun stuff. Look out for them in an Apple commercial near you. That's my prediction of the day.

From Pitchfork:

Sea Lion, therefore, has a fair amount of clutter-- expect comparisons to musically busy peers like Panda Bear or the Russian Futurists, and to the jumbled orchestral experimentation of Olivia Tremor Control-- but the album's building blocks ooze with a homespun grace. Opener "Blue Penguin" rubs the sleep out of its eyes before grinding a dirty acoustic guitar into overdriven tape. The tender horns on "Remember" are reminiscent of the gentle indie rock of Beulah before introducing a coda of warm, looped sighing. "Adventure Tour"'s high-pitched, descending choruses recall Avey Tare. "Tane Mahuta", sung in indigenous Maori, provides the sole link to McPhun's adopted home, but the song's furious strumming and dewy harmonies are straight from power- and African- (think Tabu Ley) pop.

The Ruby Suns - There are Birds (mp3)
The Ruby Suns - Tane Muhata (video)

Another Big Week in the HeeHawsphere

Collage_march_5_lowThis has been an enormous week folks. First, Sean gave me the flu over email. What an asshole. I didn't know that could be done. But the extra time at home this weekend allowed me to unlock the secret of the Peach Slice Plus smoothie from Smoothie King. It's gonna save me a ton of cash. See, I told you. Big week.

But it pales in comparison to the weeks ahead. This Thursday, I leave for the biggest of big cities, the NYC for the first non-conference of its kind, the Blogger Social. A big thanks to the lovely Christina Kerley and his excellency of the blogosphere, Drew McClellan. How these people keep up with their own businesses and do as much as they do is beyond me. Either way, I'll be meeting a ton of my favorite marketing bloggers from 8 different countries around the world. Good times and all that.

Following the blogger social will be a trip West to Ad:Tech San Francisco courtesy of the great folks over at the Madison Avenue Journal. Sean, Katie, Matt and Eric will be there, too. My cup runeth over with bloggy goodness, I tell you.

Anyway, this years topic is "Brand Strategy and the Expanding World of Digital Marketing." In the next few days, you'll see an article from me about the ongoing struggle between the brand folks and the numbers folks, and how the internets may be bringing the two together. Slowly, anyway.

Seriously, I can't wait for this. Lots of juicy topics, fantastic roundtables and some of the better presenters around including Digg's Kevin Rose, NBC's George Kliavkoff, Neilsen's Pete Blackshaw, and Barack Obama's former pastor Jeremiah Wright. Wait...no...that would be Nokia's Jeremy Wright. Only slightly less inflammatory, I hope.

I can't wait to see you guys in both New York and San Francisco. Drop me a line if you plan to be at either of these, as well. I expect many group hugs.

214.893.4622.

Is that a Twitter in Your Pocket?

<!-- /* Style Definitions */ p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal {mso-style-parent:""; margin:0in; margin-bottom:.0001pt; mso-pagination:widow-orphan; font-size:12.0pt; font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-fareast-font-family:"Times New Roman";} @page Section1 {size:8.5in 11.0in; margin:1.0in 1.25in 1.0in 1.25in; mso-header-margin:.5in; mso-footer-margin:.5in; mso-paper-source:0;} div.Section1 {page:Section1;} -->

Twitter_logo I have a theory why there are so many of the 30+ crowd and so few of the young adult crowd on twitter. Because kids did chat rooms back in the day. And the response time on those was far faster. And you could go over 140 characters. And they still ended up kind of sucking and fading away.

I wouldn’t consider micro-blogging to be a more primitive form of blogging necessarily, but mostly just an unnecessary addendum. I get the one to many broadcasting benefit, but that’s not different at all than the oh so 2006 regular blog that actually has space for a complete thought. Twitter is built on the back of the “life is in the details” approach to blogging. It’s the Seinfeld of social networking. One big show about nothing. Don’t get me wrong, I love Seinfeld, but there are very few that would be able to pull it off. 

Micro-blogging is probably here to stay, but I think as an addendum to instant messaging (like it is already on google talk), or something to add flavor to facebook or myspace (as it already does). But as a stand alone? I just can’t see it. 

And yes, you’ll see me jump over there from time to time. Sure there are usually some good comments coming through from folks like drew, lewis, armano (or rusty), and a few others. But I just assume follow the blog, I guess. It’s easier to keep up with.

Tune In Saturdays: Why?

WhyOakland, California's Why? is a fantastically difficult to classify gem. I've heard them described as hip-pop, but that fails to round up what they are exactly. While there is definitely a delicious mixture of hip hop and pop music, it's somehow a little too good, a little too folksy to fall into even made up categories. Plus, it allows you to be more defiant when you answer the simple question, "What is that you're listening to?". (English teachers, please explain how to punctuate the end of that sentence...jeez)

From Drowned in Sound:

Three’s a doozie: Elliott Smith, Mark Everett (aforementionedish, but allow it), Conor Oberst (not me but many)… these artists are canonised as masterful image-misers, capable of fully rendering an experience through words alone, drawing vivid pictures in the mind’s eye. They’re all up there on pedestals personal, around the world; time’s right for another to join them methinks, and with Alopecia Yoni Wolf has delivered a record perfectly comparable with any so-called best of the collected reference artists listed a few words ago. A collection of songs that sometimes buckle under the weight of their own graphic natures, Why?’s third album is as absorbing an experience as any initiated admirer could have hoped for. Complete newcomers are going to have their heads spun.

Why? - The Vowels Pt 2 (mp3)
Why? - Gemini (video)